UK · Payroll & compliance
Best Payroll Software for Small Businesses in the UK
BrightPay is our top pick for most UK small businesses that want payroll-only software: it files P11Ds itself, sends pension data straight to NEST, The People’s Pension and Smart Pension, and adds CIS filing if you pay subcontractors. If your budget for payroll software is zero, Employment Hero Payroll is free with no employee limit. If you already pay for Xero or Sage accounting, use their payroll and stop re-keying wages into your books.
Prices in this market moved this year, so confirm the price with the provider before you sign. BrightPay now sells only its cloud version and prices it on request, PayFit has taken its UK price list down, and Sage and Xero both lead with 90% introductory discounts.
| Top pick overall | BrightPay: payroll-only software built for small employers and their accountants, with P11D filing, direct pension links and a CIS add-on. Price on request since the desktop licence ended in April 2026. |
|---|---|
| Best free option | Employment Hero Payroll: free with no employee limit and no trial period, covering RTI, auto-enrolment and statutory pay. |
| Best for Xero users | Xero Payroll: payroll inside your accounting software at £1.50 per person a month. Not worth buying Xero for payroll alone. |
| Best for Sage users | Sage Payroll: the lowest published paid price here, £12 a month for 5 employees at full price. Sage Accounting already includes it. |
| Best for payroll + HR bundle | PayFit: payroll, leave, expenses and performance in one product for growing teams with no HR system yet. Quote only. |
| Watch out for | Introductory discounts: Sage’s 90% off lasts 3 months and Xero’s lasts 6, so budget at the full price. Bob UK Payroll (formerly Pento): no published price; consider it only if you already use HiBob. |
Best Payroll Software for Small Businesses at a Glance
All six products are on HMRC’s list of recognised payroll software, and all six file RTI submissions to HMRC. Five of them say they handle pension auto-enrolment; HiBob does not say so for Bob UK Payroll, so ask. The real differences are price, what happens to benefits in kind, and whether the tool also sells you accounting or HR.
| Provider | Published price (ex-VAT) | Free option | P11D forms | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| BrightPay | On request (cloud only from 2026/27) | Free trial | Yes, filed to HMRC | Payroll-only buyers and their accountants |
| Employment Hero Payroll | £0 free plan, any headcount | Yes | Not stated (payrolls benefits) | Zero-cost compliant payroll |
| Xero Payroll | £1.50 per person a month on top of Xero (Ignite £18 a month) | 1-month free trial, or 90% off for 6 months | No forms; payrolls benefits | Existing Xero accounting users |
| Sage Payroll | £12 a month for 5 employees; extra employees from £2.40 | 1-month free trial of Standard, or 90% off for 3 months | No (separate Sage 50 P11D) | Existing Sage accounting users |
| PayFit | On request | First month free until 31 October 2026 | Not stated | Payroll and HR in one for growing teams |
| Bob UK Payroll (formerly Pento) | Not published | No | Yes (HiBob lists P11D reporting) | Existing HiBob customers |
Sources: provider websites and HMRC’s recognised software list, checked 13 October 2026. Prices exclude VAT.
Best Payroll Software for Small Businesses
BrightPay: Best Overall Payroll Software for Small Businesses
Pick BrightPay if you want payroll-only software that covers the awkward UK jobs without extra products. It produces P11D and P11D(b) forms and sends the expenses and benefits return to HMRC from its own RTI menu, a job Sage leaves to a separate product. Pension contributions go directly to NEST, The People’s Pension and Smart Pension, and if you pay subcontractors, BrightPay’s BrightCIS add-on files Construction Industry Scheme returns.
It is built for small and medium employers and for the accountants and bureaus who run payroll for them, so several people can work in the same payroll at once.
Where it falls short: you cannot price it from the website. BrightPay for Windows, which had a published annual price for each employee band, was discontinued after 5 April 2026. The cloud version is quoted through a “Get a Price” form or the sales team. Ask for the price at today’s headcount and at the headcount you expect in two years, and run a payroll in the free trial before you commit.
See our full BrightPay review.
Employment Hero Payroll: Best Free Payroll Software
Pick Employment Hero Payroll if you need compliant payroll at no cost. The free plan has no employee limit, no trial period and needs no card, and it covers RTI submissions, pension auto-enrolment, SSP and SMP, payslips, P60s and an employee self-service portal. The free products on HMRC’s own list are all for businesses with fewer than 10 employees.
If you later want HR tools or someone to run payroll for you, Employment Hero sells both on the same platform.
Where it falls short: the free plan does not mention P11D forms; Employment Hero describes calculating payrolled benefits instead. Nor does it mention the Construction Industry Scheme, so test CIS before relying on it. The paid services are priced per head with minimums: for new customers from 1 November 2026, Managed Payroll costs £14 per employee a month with a £140 monthly minimum.
See our full Employment Hero Payroll review, or compare it with other free tools in our guide to the best free payroll software.
Xero Payroll: Best for Existing Xero Accounting Users
Pick Xero Payroll if you already keep your books in Xero. Pay runs post straight to your accounts, so wages are never typed into two systems. Xero files RTI after every pay run, assesses and enrols staff for pensions with direct links to Nest and The People’s Pension, and works out statutory sick, maternity, paternity, shared parental, adoption and bereavement pay.
Payroll costs £1.50 per person a month on Ignite (£18 a month). Grow (£39) includes 1 person, Comprehensive (£55) includes 5 and Ultimate (£70) includes 10, with extra people at £1.50, or £1 on Ultimate.
Where it falls short: it only makes sense with the accounting subscription. At 25 people on Grow you pay £75 a month (£39 plus 24 people at £1.50). The first 6 months are 90% off, so set your budget at the full price. Xero describes reporting benefits through payroll rather than producing P11D forms.
Payroll inside your accounting software also ties the two together. Switching either one later means moving both or running a split set-up, so if you are choosing accounting software now, judge its payroll as part of that choice.
See our full Xero Payroll review.
Sage Payroll: Best for Sage Accounting Users
Pick Sage Payroll (listed by HMRC as Sage Business Cloud Payroll) if you already use Sage Accounting, which includes it, or if you want the lowest published paid price for a team of 5. Payroll Essentials costs £12 a month for 5 employees, with extra employees from £2.40 each, up to 150. Sage sells every plan with HR features; Standard (£23 a month, extra employees from £4.40) adds core HR capabilities, and Premium (£34, from £6.40) adds fuller HR. Every plan includes RTI, pension auto-enrolment and payslips.
Where it falls short: the price Sage shows first is the discount. Its page leads with 90% off for 3 months, £1.20 a month on Essentials, so month 4 costs ten times month 1. At 25 employees, Essentials costs about £60 a month at full price (£12 plus 20 employees at £2.40). Sage’s cloud payroll does not produce P11Ds; HMRC lists Sage 50 P11D as a separate product. Sage states there are no long-term contracts, so you can leave if the full price does not work for you.
See our full Sage Payroll review.
PayFit: Best Payroll and HR Bundle for Growing Teams
Pick PayFit if you have no HR system yet and want payroll, leave and absences, expenses and performance reviews in one product. That replaces two subscriptions with one, which is the only reason to choose it over a payroll-only tool.
Where it falls short: PayFit no longer publishes UK prices, so you need a demo to get a number. Until 31 October 2026 it offers the first month free. Because you pay for HR features too, it costs more than it needs to if you only want payroll. If you already run BambooHR, HiBob or Personio, PayFit duplicates the HR system you have.
See our full PayFit review.
Bob UK Payroll (formerly Pento): Only If You Already Use HiBob
Consider Bob UK Payroll only if your HR already runs on HiBob’s Bob. HiBob publishes no UK payroll price, so the five tools above are easier to price and to start. The product was Pento until HiBob bought it in February 2024; HMRC now lists it as Bob UK Payroll.
What Does Small Business Payroll Software Cost in the UK?
At 25 employees, the published full prices run from £0 to £75 a month, and every one of these tools files RTI to HMRC. The price gap comes from what else you buy: accounting, HR, or nothing.
| Monthly cost at 25 employees (full price, ex-VAT) | Cost | What you also get |
|---|---|---|
| Employment Hero Payroll, free plan | £0 | Payroll only |
| Xero Ignite plus payroll (£18 + 25 × £1.50) | £55.50 | Accounting software |
| Sage Payroll Essentials (£12 + 20 × £2.40) | About £60 | Some HR features |
| Xero Grow plus payroll (£39 + 24 × £1.50) | £75 | Fuller accounting plan |
| BrightPay, PayFit, Bob UK Payroll | On request | Ask for a written quote |
Three costs catch small businesses out:
- The end of the introductory discount. Sage’s 90% off lasts 3 months and Xero’s lasts 6. Put the full price in your budget from day one.
- Per-employee steps. Base-plus-per-head pricing looks small at 5 staff and grows with every hire. Price your plan at the headcount you expect next year, not today.
- Monthly minimums on services. Employment Hero’s Managed Payroll has a £140 monthly minimum, so a 5-person team pays the same as a 10-person one.
How to Choose Payroll Software for a Small Business
Start with what you already pay for. If your books are in Xero or Sage, their payroll is the default, and a separate tool has to earn its place. If they are not, choose between free (Employment Hero), payroll-only (BrightPay) and payroll plus HR (PayFit) on the questions below.
- Do you give benefits in kind? From 6 April 2027, employers must report company cars, car fuel, vans, van fuel and employer-provided medical benefits through payroll, and most other benefits follow from April 2028. Ask every provider how it handles payrolled benefits now. Until then, BrightPay files P11Ds itself; Sage needs a separate product.
- Which pension provider do you use? A direct link saves a manual upload every pay run. BrightPay and Xero both link to NEST and The People’s Pension; check yours by name before you sign.
- Do you pay subcontractors under CIS? BrightPay offers BrightCIS, and Xero calculates CIS deductions and helps you file CIS returns. The others do not mention CIS on the pages we checked, so ask before you sign.
- How far will you grow? Sage Payroll goes up to 150 employees. Employment Hero’s free plan has no limit.
If you are weighing these against the wider UK market, our best payroll software in the UK guide covers larger employers too.
Frequently Asked Questions About Payroll Software for UK Small Businesses
Do small businesses legally need payroll software in the UK?
No law names a tool, but every employer must send HMRC a Full Payment Submission on or before each payday, which in practice means using payroll software. HMRC’s own Basic PAYE Tools is free for businesses with fewer than 10 employees. HMRC’s description of it does not mention pensions, so you would handle auto-enrolment separately.
Is there genuinely free payroll software for UK small businesses?
Yes. HMRC lists several free products, including its own Basic PAYE Tools, for businesses with fewer than 10 employees. Employment Hero Payroll is free at any headcount, with no trial period, and covers RTI, auto-enrolment and statutory pay.
What is the cheapest paid payroll software in the UK for small businesses?
Of the tools that publish prices, Sage Payroll Essentials is cheapest for a small team: £12 a month for up to 5 employees at full price. At 25 employees Xero Ignite plus payroll (£55.50) edges below Sage (about £60), and includes accounting. BrightPay’s cloud version is priced on request, so it cannot be compared here.
Does payroll software handle pension auto-enrolment automatically?
BrightPay, Employment Hero, Xero, Sage and PayFit all assess staff, enrol them and calculate contributions; HiBob does not say whether Bob UK Payroll does. The legal minimum is 3% from the employer and 8% in total, on qualifying earnings. What varies is which pension providers each tool sends data to directly, so check that your scheme is one of them.
Can a non-specialist set up payroll software without an accountant?
Usually, yes. The first pay run is the hard part, so rehearse it before you go live: BrightPay has a free trial, Employment Hero’s plan is free, and Sage’s first 3 months cost £1.20 a month on Essentials. PayFit and Bob UK Payroll start with a sales demo, so ask what set-up help the price includes.
What is the difference between payroll software and a payroll bureau?
With software you still enter the pay data, process starters and leavers and meet HMRC deadlines; a bureau or managed service does that for you. The price gap is large: Employment Hero’s Managed Payroll costs £14 per employee a month, £350 at 25 staff, against £0 for its free software. A managed service earns that cost when pay is irregular, turnover is high or nobody in-house has time to run payroll.
How We Reviewed Payroll Software for Small Businesses
We shortlisted payroll software sold to UK employers with 1 to 50 staff and confirmed each product on HMRC’s list of recognised payroll software. We then judged each on full price at 5 and 25 employees, what the entry plan includes, P11D and benefits handling, pension links and CIS support.
WhichPayroll is an independent comparison site for payroll, EOR, and contractor management platforms. We do not sell these services and do not accept payment for editorial placement or rankings. We may earn a commission if you book a demo or request a quote through links on this page.
Rankings reflect the editorial team's independent assessment and were not reviewed or approved by any provider before publication.
Providers Reviewed
- BrightPay
- Employment Hero Payroll
- Xero Payroll
- Sage Payroll
- PayFit
- Bob UK Payroll (formerly Pento)
Data Sources
- Provider pricing and product pages for all listed platforms (checked 13 October 2026)
- HMRC’s list of recognised payroll software and GOV.UK guidance on RTI, Basic PAYE Tools, workplace pensions and payrolling benefits
- Provider help centre documentation
- WhichPayroll provider score composite data (see sources & data)