UK · Payroll & compliance
Brightpay Vs Iris Payroll
Both BrightPay and Iris Payroll have earned loyal bureau and accountant user bases over decades of UK payroll work. In 2026 neither sits still. BrightPay for Windows was discontinued after 5 April 2026, so BrightPay Cloud is now the only route.
Iris Payroll Basics was reported to end in April 2026, which pushes its free users toward a paid Staffology subscription. Comparing these two products in 2026 means comparing two moving targets.
The question of which fits your practice depends less on feature lists than on how each handles the transition, what it costs at bureau scale, and where each falls short for your specific compliance obligations.
A bureau manager running 30 SMB clients on monthly cycles cares about cost-per-payslip and P11D handling, not interface polish.
The core tension is structural. BrightPay is built for accountants and bureaus, but it publishes no price list, so we cannot say how its bureau cost compares.
Iris Staffology Payroll charges per payslip, publishes its entry price and offers an open API. You are not choosing between a cheap option and an expensive one. You are choosing between two different operating models.
Quick Verdict: BrightPay vs Iris Payroll
- Built for accountants, payroll bureaus and SMEs
- HMRC-recognised
- Supported pension providers include NEST, The People’s Pension, Smart Pension
- Part of the Bright family (BrightCIS, BrightBooks, TimeKeeper)
- API-first design with an open API for custom integrations
- Staffology Bureau can be white-labelled with your logo and colours
- CIS and umbrella company payroll handled in the software
- Published price for 1 to 50 payslips a month
Choose BrightPay if you run a payroll bureau for multiple SMB clients and cost efficiency is the primary driver. Get a BrightPay cloud quote first: it publishes no prices, so we cannot say it is cheaper.
Choose Iris Staffology if your bureau handles CIS contractors, wants a white-labelled client portal, or has bespoke internal systems requiring API integration. The per-payslip price is public up to 50 payslips a month; confirm P11D support in writing.
BrightPay may suit bureaux, but it publishes no price, so get a quote; IRIS has a published entry price, an open API and a white-label bureau portal.
Last checked: 2026-10-14 · WhichPayroll evaluates comparison pages quarterly. No paid placement.
Price from
BrightPayBy quote
IRIS PayrollFrom £43/month; quote above 50 payslips
Best for
BrightPayPayroll bureaux and accountants
IRIS PayrollAccountants and payroll bureaux
Watch out for
BrightPayNo published prices; Windows version discontinued
IRIS PayrollBespoke quote above 50 payslips a month
How evaluated: Live UK provider pricing and product pages; affiliate links used where programmes are live.
BrightPay vs Iris Payroll at a Glance
For a senior People Ops or bureau manager scanning this in five minutes, the headline is that both products are HMRC-recognised, both list auto-enrolment support, and both serve UK accountants and SMBs. The differences sit in the operating model.
BrightPay is payroll inside a wider Bright family (BrightCIS, BrightBooks, TimeKeeper), sold separately. IRIS sells Staffology Payroll, Staffology Bureau, Staffology HR and Payroll Professional as separate products.
Whether BrightPay is cheaper for standard PAYE work depends on a quote we could not see. If your client list includes CIS contractors, API-driven internal systems or a need for a white-labelled portal, IRIS has confirmed features for each.
The split across the rest of this comparison is price on a BrightPay quote against IRIS’s published rate, and the deciding factor is your client mix.
BrightPay for Windows was discontinued after 5 April 2026, and Iris Payroll Basics was reported to end in April 2026. Both create migration pressure. Bureaus on either legacy product cannot stand still. The question is which migration path makes more sense for your specific workflow.
Full Comparison Table: BrightPay vs Iris Payroll
| Criterion | BrightPay | Iris Payroll (Staffology) |
|---|---|---|
| Product type | Cloud payroll (Windows version discontinued after 5 April 2026) | Cloud payroll (API-first, SaaS) |
| HMRC recognised | Yes | Yes |
| Bureau licence | Bureau workflows supported; licence terms not published | Staffology Bureau (quote-only) |
| Pricing model (in-house) | Annual and monthly plans; no price list | £43/month flat for 1 to 20 payslips; £2.15 per payslip for 21 to 50; bespoke above 50 (ex VAT) |
| Pricing model (bureau) | Not published | Quote-based |
| RTI (FPS/EPS) | Yes, automated | Yes, automated |
| Auto-enrolment integrations | Supported providers include NEST, The People’s Pension, Smart Pension | Provider list not confirmed on IRIS’s page; ask for it |
| P11D benefits-in-kind | Not confirmed; ask BrightPay | Not confirmed for Staffology; ask IRIS |
| CIS support | Via BrightCIS, a separate Bright product | Yes, IRIS says Staffology handles CIS and umbrella company payroll |
| Gender Pay Gap reporting | Not confirmed | Not confirmed |
| Public API | None found | Open API (API-first design) |
| Employee cap | Quote needed above 250 employees for a single employer | Bespoke quote above 50 payslips a month |
| Data residency | Not confirmed (BrightPay says secure hosting) | Not confirmed |
| Support model | Not confirmed | Not confirmed; ask for any SLA in writing |
| Implementation time | Not published | Not published |
The most decision-relevant gap is price visibility. IRIS publishes a per-payslip rate up to 50 payslips a month and quotes above that. BrightPay publishes no price list.
For practices running 20-100 clients, get both quotes before any feature-level discussion begins.
What Are the Key Differences Between BrightPay and Iris Payroll?
The two products diverge on three axes that matter to a buyer in 2026.
Operating model. BrightPay is one payroll product in a wider Bright family; CIS (BrightCIS) is sold separately.
Iris is a product family.
Staffology Payroll sits beside Staffology Bureau, Staffology HR and Payroll Professional.
That breadth helps if your bureau wants HR and benefits in one ecosystem; it adds choice to work through if you only need payroll.
Pricing structure. BrightPay publishes no price list. IRIS charges a flat £43 a month for 1 to 20 payslips and £2.15 per payslip from 21 to 50, and quotes above that.
At 450 monthly payslips IRIS quotes bespoke, so any total is an extrapolation, and BrightPay’s figure needs a quote.
Compliance depth. Both list HMRC recognition and auto-enrolment pensions support. IRIS says Staffology handles CIS and umbrella company payroll. BrightPay sells CIS as a separate product (BrightCIS). We could not confirm P11D or Gender Pay Gap reporting for either, so ask both.
If your clients have company car schemes or 250+ employees (the Gender Pay Gap threshold), get the answer in writing before you sign.
The transition timelines also differ. BrightPay for Windows was discontinued after 5 April 2026. Iris Payroll Basics was reported to end in April 2026, with Staffology Payroll as the paid replacement.
Both vendors are pushing legacy users toward paid cloud products.
What Is BrightPay and What Does It Offer?
BrightPay is a UK and Ireland payroll product from Bright Software Group. It is built for accountants, payroll bureaus and small and medium businesses.
The product is HMRC-recognised and lists NEST, The People’s Pension and Smart Pension as supported pension providers.
BrightPay for Windows was discontinued after 5 April 2026, so BrightPay Cloud is the product to buy. We could not confirm whether the Connect portal is included at no charge.
BrightPay says annual and monthly plans are available. It publishes no price list, and we could not confirm how a mid-period headcount change is billed, so ask.
For bureaus, the licensing model is the headline. BrightPay supports bureau workflows, but its bureau licence terms are not published. Ask whether the licence is flat-rate and how many employers and employees it covers.
For a practice running 30 SMB clients on monthly payroll, get the quote before you assume it is cheaper.
Review-site data was not loadable when we checked, so we do not quote a recommendation rate.
What we could not find matters too. BrightPay’s pages list no P11D module and no public API.
They list no Gender Pay Gap reporting tool either. If your clients only need standard payroll, those gaps may not matter.
For practices with company car schemes, taxable benefits, or 250-employee clients, ask for written confirmation, or plan a parallel toolset or a different vendor. See the BrightPay review for the deeper product walkthrough.
What Is Iris Payroll and What Does It Offer?
Iris is a UK software group whose payroll range includes Staffology Payroll (cloud, API-first), Staffology Bureau (for payroll providers, quote-based) and Payroll Professional (for complex payroll needs).
Iris Payroll Basics, the free entry-level product, was reported to end in April 2026 with Staffology as the paid replacement. We could not confirm the date on IRIS’s own site.
Staffology is the headline product for new buyers in 2026. Pricing is published, ex VAT: £43 a month flat for 1 to 20 payslips, then £2.15 per payslip for 21 to 50 payslips a month. IRIS’s own text reads two ways for the 21 to 50 band, so confirm in writing how it bills.
Bureau customers look at Staffology Bureau, which is quote-only.
Both products are HMRC-recognised. We could not confirm IRIS’s pension provider list, so ask for it.
The integration story is where IRIS is clearest. It describes Staffology as API-first, with an open API for custom integrations and pre-built connectors to tools such as QuickBooks and Xero. We could not confirm webhooks, or that no rival offers the same.
We could not confirm native P11D reporting in Staffology. IRIS’s Payroll Professional page mentions P11Ds only as documents delivered through its employee portal.
IRIS says its software handles CIS and umbrella company payroll. We could not confirm Gender Pay Gap or IR35 handling.
The trade-off is cost and procurement friction. Staffology Bureau pricing needs a sales conversation; Staffology Payroll pricing scales with payslip volume.
For high-volume bureau work, per-payslip pricing grows with every payslip, so compare it with a BrightPay quote. The full breakdown sits in the Iris Payroll review.
How Do BrightPay and Iris Payroll Compare on Features: Bureau Multi-Client Tools?
Bureau workflow features are where multi-client practices spend most of their time, and the two products handle this differently.
BrightPay says it supports high-volume processing, multi-user collaboration and bureau workflows, within the wider Bright ecosystem.
We could not confirm the client dashboard, bulk RTI submission or client-portal detail from BrightPay’s pages, so test them in a demo.
IRIS Staffology Bureau is aimed at payroll providers, and IRIS says you can white-label it with your company name, logo and colours on the platform and client portal.
We could not confirm named account managers or formal support tiers for either product. If your own clients hold you to an SLA, ask both vendors for the terms in writing.
The decision splits on volume and complexity, and neither price is public enough for us to name a crossover. Run both quotes at your own client count.
If you need a white-labelled client portal or API-driven set-up, IRIS has confirmed both. If you do not, price decides. For mid-market clients needing P11D or Gender Pay Gap reporting, ask both vendors.
We found no published evidence of a client count at which either product wins.
Section payoff: match the bureau tooling to your client count and complexity, not to your software preference. Get both quotes before you decide.
How Do BrightPay and Iris Payroll Compare on Pricing: Bureau Cost at Scale?
Cost comparison between these two products requires separating the bureau and single-employer use cases, because the pricing structures are fundamentally different.
BrightPay for Windows (discontinued after 5 April 2026):
- Desktop prices are no longer listed on BrightPay’s site
- Bureau licence: terms not published
The Windows version will not be relicensed for 2026/27.
BrightPay Cloud: No published tier table. BrightPay says annual and monthly pricing plans are available. We could not confirm the annual discount or how a mid-period headcount change is billed.
Ask BrightPay (brightpay.co.uk/pricing) for a quote. We could not confirm whether the Connect add-on is included at no charge.
Iris Staffology Payroll (2026 published pricing):
- Flat fee: £43/month for 1 to 20 payslips per month (ex VAT)
- 21 to 50 payslips: £2.15 per payslip per month; 51 and above needs a bespoke quote
- Bureau (Staffology Bureau): quote-only
Worked example at bureau scale. A bureau running 30 clients, each with 15 employees on monthly payroll, processes 450 payslips per month. Note: 450 payslips sits well above IRIS's published 50-payslip band; the figure below extrapolates the £2.15 rate and should be treated as indicative only. For actual bureau-scale pricing, request a bespoke quote from IRIS.
- BrightPay: price needs a quote, so we cannot give a figure
- Iris Staffology: £43 flat + (430 further payslips x £2.15) = £43 + £924.50 = £967.50/month, approximately £11,610/year. Charging £2.15 on all 450 gives the same £967.50. This is an extrapolation; IRIS quotes bespoke above 50 payslips.
The per-payslip model grows with every payslip, so the IRIS total at bureau volume is large and quote-based. Whether it exceeds BrightPay depends on a quote we could not see. The gap may narrow when API integration or a white-labelled portal enters the calculation. For full per-tier costs see the BrightPay pricing guide.
Ask BrightPay how a headcount change is billed. We could not confirm how cloud billing treats a month of seasonal or temporary staff.
A bureau with retail or hospitality clients, where headcounts spike at Christmas or summer, should get the billing basis in writing before signing.
A finance lead who wants predictable per-quarter costs needs that answer for any client with seasonal payroll.
Section payoff: We cannot say BrightPay is cheaper until it publishes or quotes a price. IRIS’s cost is public up to 50 payslips a month and quote-based above that, so run both side by side.
How Do BrightPay and Iris Payroll Compare on Compliance: HMRC RTI and Auto-Enrolment?
Both products are HMRC-recognised and support Real Time Information submissions. The compliance differences sit in adjacent obligations.
RTI accuracy and reliability. We could not load review-site data, so we do not rate RTI reliability. Both are HMRC-recognised.
We found no evidence of an RTI quality gap in either direction, but we did not test submissions.
Auto-enrolment provider integration. BrightPay lists NEST, The People’s Pension and Smart Pension as supported providers. We could not confirm IRIS’s provider list, so ask for it.
For clients on NEST or The People’s Pension, BrightPay’s list covers them. For clients with occupational schemes through other providers, check both lists first.
P11D benefits-in-kind. We could not confirm native P11D reporting for either product.
Ask both vendors in writing.
If the answer is no, bureaus with clients that have company car schemes, private medical insurance or other taxable benefits need a separate tool or service for P11Ds.
CIS and IR35. IRIS says Staffology handles CIS. BrightPay sells CIS as a separate Bright product, BrightCIS, which supports submission of Construction Industry Returns. Ask how it works with payroll.
We could not confirm IR35 off-payroll handling for either product; ask.
Gender Pay Gap reporting. We could not confirm a Gender Pay Gap module for either product.
For bureaus with 250+ employee clients (the legal threshold for GPG reporting), ask both vendors whether the software covers it.
Section payoff: Both are HMRC-recognised, and that is the parity we can confirm. For P11D, Gender Pay Gap, IR35 and pension provider coverage we found nothing that separates them, so ask both for written confirmation. IRIS says CIS is inside Staffology; BrightPay sells BrightCIS separately.
How Do BrightPay and Iris Payroll Compare on Scalability: Multi-Client Bureau Onboarding?
Onboarding new clients into a bureau workflow is a recurring task that the underlying tooling either eases or frustrates.
We could not confirm BrightPay’s client onboarding steps from its published pages, so test a mid-year client, the most common bureau scenario, in a trial.
Check how each product loads year-to-date figures and runs an alignment FPS.
IRIS’s Staffology Bureau pages describe cloud payroll for payroll providers. We could not confirm an onboarding template or bulk import.
Ask IRIS what a typical bureau migration involves and how long it takes.
Staffology’s open API could allow programmatic client set-up if you have development resource; confirm what the API covers.
The white-labelling and client portal differ. We could not confirm that BrightPay’s Connect portal offers branding.
IRIS says Staffology Bureau can be white-labelled with your company name, logo and colours on the platform and client portal. For bureaus that compete on brand, ask BrightPay what it brands.
We could not compare consolidated multi-client reporting (P60 batches, RTI summaries, pension exports) from published pages, so ask for a demo of each.
Section payoff: For white-labelled client portals and API-driven set-up, IRIS has confirmed features. We could not confirm onboarding speed for either, so test it.
How Do BrightPay and Iris Payroll Compare on Support: SLA and Response Time?
Support quality matters for a bureau with its own client commitments to maintain.
We could not confirm BrightPay’s support channels, phone availability or response times from its published pages. Ask which channels each licence tier includes.
BrightPay’s support pages list separate sections for Cloud, BrightCIS and Desktop support.
We could not confirm IRIS’s response-time tiers or named account managers for Staffology. Get any service level in writing.
For a bureau that has promised its own clients same-day response on payroll queries, a written SLA from either vendor is the test.
We did not compare documentation quality.
We did not assess user communities.
Ask each vendor for reference customers at your client count.
Section payoff: We could not confirm either vendor’s service levels from published pages, so make written support terms a condition of choosing either.
Which Should You Choose: BrightPay or Iris Payroll?
The decision splits cleanly along client profile, not along software quality.
In our assessment, the choice rests on a BrightPay quote we could not see. IRIS has the confirmed edge where an open API, a white-labelled bureau portal or CIS inside the payroll product are real needs.
Choose BrightPay if…
- You run a payroll bureau for SMB clients with standard payroll obligations (PAYE, auto-enrolment, RTI) and you have confirmed P11D support or have no P11D clients
- Cost is the primary driver and BrightPay’s quote beats IRIS’s per-payslip price at your volume
- You are already using BrightPay for Windows and need to move to BrightPay Cloud
- Your clients use NEST, The People’s Pension or Smart Pension for auto-enrolment, which BrightPay lists as supported
- You already use other Bright products or want to add them later
BrightPay may not fit if your clients have P11D obligations it cannot confirm, if you need a public API for internal workflow integration (we found none), or if you have data-residency requirements: we could not confirm where BrightPay hosts data.
Choose Iris Payroll if…
- Your bureau serves clients with P11D benefits-in-kind obligations (company cars, private medical insurance, other taxable benefits) and IRIS confirms in writing that Staffology covers them
- You have built or plan to build internal workflow tools that require a payroll API
- Your client base includes CIS subcontractors and you want CIS inside the payroll product
- You are migrating from Iris Payroll Basics and want to stay within the Iris ecosystem
- Your bureau serves larger employers (250+ employees) and IRIS confirms Gender Pay Gap reporting
- You want a white-labelled client portal for your own brand
Iris Staffology may not fit if the £43 a month base plus £2.15 per payslip exceeds BrightPay’s quote at your volume. Ask IRIS how long a bureau migration takes; we could not confirm a timescale.
The cleaner shortcut: get both quotes at your client count. If you need an open API, a white-labelled portal or CIS inside the payroll product, IRIS has those confirmed.
If your client base is standard PAYE, NEST and auto-enrolment work with none of that, the BrightPay quote decides it, and we cannot say today which is cheaper.
What Are the Best Alternatives to BrightPay and Iris Payroll?
If neither product fits, the UK SMB payroll market has three credible alternatives worth considering.
Sage Payroll. The default incumbent for many UK practices, with strong Sage 50 Accounts integration and HMRC-recognised RTI handling. Sage Payroll Essentials starts at £12 a month (ex VAT) with 5 employees included.
Sage is the right choice if your practice already runs Sage 50 Accounts and wants tight integration. Switch to Sage if your accountancy stack is Sage-centric.
Xero Payroll. Cloud-native, HMRC-recognised, and sold inside Xero’s plans: Comprehensive includes 5 people and Ultimate 10, while Ignite adds £1.50 per person. Xero Payroll is the right choice for in-house teams that already run Xero accounting and want a single-vendor stack.
We found no bureau licence equivalent to BrightPay’s, and Xero caps payroll at 200 people. Switch to Xero Payroll if you are running Xero accounting and your client list is sub-50 employee SMBs.
Moorepay. Outsourced UK payroll bureau service rather than software. Right for in-house teams that want to outsource the entire payroll function to a UK-based bureau. Not directly comparable to BrightPay or Iris on a software-only basis.
Switch to Moorepay if your decision is build-vs-buy and you have decided to buy.
For the full UK payroll software comparison, the alternatives shortlist scales further depending on bureau size and integration requirements.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is BrightPay desktop still available in 2026?
No. BrightPay says BrightPay for Windows was discontinued after 5 April 2026. Previous tax-year versions can be downloaded, but no 2026/27 desktop licence is sold.
Anyone still on the Windows version has no 2026/27 release to run payroll on, so the move to BrightPay Cloud is not optional.
What replaces Iris Payroll Basics?
Reports say IRIS points Basics users to Staffology Payroll; we could not confirm this on IRIS’s own site. It is not a like-for-like swap: Payroll Basics was free, while Staffology Payroll starts at £43 a month for 1 to 20 payslips, with £2.15 per payslip for 21 to 50.
Users who were on Basics for small or single-employer payroll face a meaningful cost increase. BrightPay is an alternative to quote, but it publishes no prices, so we cannot say it is cheaper.
Does BrightPay handle P11D benefits-in-kind reporting?
We could not confirm it. BrightPay’s pages list no P11D reporting, so ask before you rely on it. If it is absent, employers with P11D obligations (company cars, private medical insurance, taxable loans) need a separate tool.
Bureaus can use third-party benefits-in-kind services.
We could not confirm native P11D in Staffology either, so ask IRIS too.
Which is better for a payroll bureau with 50+ clients?
It depends on client profile and on a BrightPay quote we could not see. IRIS’s per-payslip billing grows with every payslip, and above 50 payslips a month IRIS quotes bespoke.
If you need CIS, API integration or a white-labelled portal, IRIS has those confirmed. Get a BrightPay bureau quote and an IRIS Staffology Bureau quote at your client count and price both side by side.
Does Iris Staffology have a REST API?
Yes, IRIS describes Staffology as API-first, with an open API for custom integrations. We could not confirm webhooks or the scope of the API, and we cannot say it is the only one in UK payroll.
We found no public API for BrightPay; we did not check Xero or Sage here.
If you have built internal systems or client dashboards, an API can remove manual export steps. Without development resource, it does not change the cost comparison.
How does BrightPay cloud pricing work after the desktop retirement?
BrightPay Cloud has no published tier table; request a quote at brightpay.co.uk/pricing. BrightPay says annual and monthly pricing plans are available.
We could not confirm the annual discount, how a headcount change is billed, or whether Connect is included. Ask for all three in writing.
Can I run BrightPay and Iris in parallel during a migration?
Yes, for different employers. Bureaus often migrate clients in waves, running part of the client list on each product during a transition quarter. Do not run the same employer’s payroll in both systems at once.
Migrating a single employer mid-year needs year-to-date figures loaded and an alignment FPS in the new system, so check each vendor’s guidance. The practical limit is your team’s capacity to manage two systems at once.
How We Compared BrightPay and Iris Payroll
WhichPayroll is an independent comparison site for global payroll, EOR, and contractor management platforms. We do not sell these services and do not accept payment for editorial placement or rankings. We may earn a commission if you book a demo or request a quote through links on this page.
Rankings reflect the editorial team’s independent assessment and were not reviewed or approved by any provider before publication.
Data Sources
- Provider pricing pages for all listed platforms (verified October 2026)
- Vendor product pages (review sites were not loadable in October 2026)
- Provider help centre documentation and country guides
- WhichPayroll provider score composite data (see sources & data)
Research Approach
Both providers were assessed against the same criteria: pricing model and total employment cost, entity model and compliance infrastructure, country coverage depth and quality, platform usability and onboarding, customer support model, and published vendor information. Neither provider was engaged for a paid pilot or contract. Last updated October 2026.